Skip to content
world

Carl Sagan Has a Message for Trump and Xi

Ottawa Life Magazine columnist Chris Pereira uses Carl Sagan's cosmic perspective to ask a pointed question: what would the author of the Pale Blue Dot make of today's great-power rivalry?

·ottown·3 min read
Carl Sagan Has a Message for Trump and Xi
106

Ottawa Life Magazine's Chris Pereira opens his latest essay with a deceptively quiet scene: stepping off a plane at Heathrow, boarding the Elizabeth Line into London, and finding himself seated next to a stranger holding two bouquets of summer flowers. It's the kind of small, human moment that stops you mid-scroll — and Pereira uses it as a springboard into one of the bigger questions of our era: what would Carl Sagan say about Donald Trump and Xi Jinping?

The Pale Blue Dot, Remembered

In 1990, NASA's Voyager 1 spacecraft turned its camera back toward Earth from roughly six billion kilometres away. The resulting image showed our planet as a mote of dust suspended in a sunbeam — what Sagan famously called the Pale Blue Dot. His meditation on that photograph remains one of the most humbling pieces of writing in the English language. "Every king and peasant, every young couple in love, every mother and father, hopeful child... every saint and sinner in the history of our species lived there," Sagan wrote. On a pale blue dot.

That image came to mind, Pereira suggests, when the universe nudged him toward the man with the flowers on the Elizabeth Line. There is something about an ordinary human being carrying beauty through a crowded transit car — not performing anything, not broadcasting a brand, just carrying flowers — that makes the noise of geopolitics feel very far away.

What Sagan Would See in 2025

The rivalry between the United States and China has reshaped global trade, supply chains, and diplomatic relationships at a pace that feels genuinely historic. Tariffs and counter-tariffs have been swapped like blows. Semiconductor export controls have redrawn the map of global technology. Taiwan remains a flashpoint. And through it all, two of the most powerful men alive have staked enormous amounts of national prestige on looking tough.

Sagan, who died in 1996, never saw any of this. But his writing anticipated the shape of it with uncomfortable precision. He worried about a world where tribal thinking — national, ideological, religious — would prevent humanity from confronting the shared threats that respect no border: climate change, pandemics, the proliferation of weapons capable of ending civilization. "Our planet is a lonely speck in the great enveloping cosmic dark," he wrote. "In our obscurity, in all this vastness, there is no hint that help will come from elsewhere to save us from ourselves."

The Man With the Flowers

Pereira doesn't argue that Sagan would have been naive about power politics. The Cosmos host understood realpolitik. What he demanded, instead, was a sense of proportion — the ability to zoom out far enough to remember what the stakes actually are, for the species, not just the superpower.

The man on the Elizabeth Line with his bouquets probably wasn't thinking about any of this. He was probably thinking about whoever was waiting for those flowers. And that, Pereira implies, is closer to the right scale than anything happening in a Mar-a-Lago dining room or a Zhongnanhai conference hall.

It's a small essay that asks a large question. Worth the read.

Source: Ottawa Life Magazine / ottawalife.com

Stay in the know, Ottawa

Get the best local news, new restaurant openings, events, and hidden gems delivered to your inbox every week.